Posts Categorized: Current thinking

See you in court

A council in Hertfordshire has threatened a legal challenge to Planning Policy Guidance in respect of barn conversions under the GPDO (DCS Number 400-013-437).

The basis of the council’s refusal of prior approval for the residential conversion of the barn was that it would result in a dwelling in an isolated location. An appeal inspector pointed out, however, that Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) confirms, in relation to the Class Q permitted development rights, that

Read more on See you in court…

Value judgments

There has been head-scratching here at the DCP Blog about how to recognise a ‘valued landscape’ (Paragraph 109 of the NPPF). Valued by whom?

In Leckhampton, Cheltenham (DCS Number 200-004-992) the secretary of state agreed with his inspector that the site, whilst not designated, had its own intrinsic charm which gave it value and that it was a locally valued landscape.

Read more on Value judgments…

Post Brexit

An appellant whose plans to build a house within 400m of the Thames Basin Heaths Special Protection Area have been thwarted due to the presence of protected birds in the SPA has claimed the country’s impending departure from the European Union in support of the proposal (DCS Number 400-013-119).

Read more on Post Brexit…

Out of sight, out of mind

Not so long ago the view of inspectors was generally that the impact on openness in the green belt had little to do with whether or not development could be seen. Any physical structure would necessarily reduce openness, it was reasoned. A recent court case appears to have changed things somewhat radically, however.

Read more on Out of sight, out of mind…

A trail of lawsuits

You don’t have to look far to find an example from Donald Trump’s trail of lawsuits, referred to by President Obama in his farewell address in Philadelphia. An inspector has recently cited Trump International Golf Club Scotland v Scottish Ministers [2015] in declining to issue a lawful development certificate for the retention of a rear extension at a house in east London (DCS Number 400-012-343).

Read more on A trail of lawsuits…